Dealing in Despair McLeod argues that race and class are inextricably intertwined? Schooled by Social Class-- Pierre Bourdieu: The ambitious Brothers have fared little better. Although "rags to riches" transformations are possible in American society, they are rare and rely as much on chance as on effort.
What kinds of aspirations do the Brothers have for future employment? How does McLeod see social structure and culture coming together to determine individuals' class position?
Interspersed with the excerpts of interviews is a lot of theory on the subject, since this is an academic work, and a discussion of field methods in sociology. MacLeod provides a thorough account of the aspirations and expectations of two male peer groups residing in a public housing project.
The Brothers have higher dreams, but even these are tempered. That's the kind of story they all have. What is the difference between aspirations and expectations? Lastly, this book describes in vivid detail what all the statistics report: Nielsen Book Data Subjects.
What role does race play in the successes and failures of the Hallway Hangers versus the Brothers?
Juan wants to be a cook, takes a special vocational education cooking course in high school, ends up looking for work as a mechanic and then, when that fails, ends up at McDonald's. Their recent arrival caused them to think that they were upwardly mobile. MacLeod introduces some theories of social reproduction.
Part Two follows the Hallway Hangers and the Brothers into adulthood. What he finds are two groups in the project - the "Hallway Hangers", white, drug-using, school-skipping miscreants, and the "Brothers", black, hard-studying, 'good kids'.
Jay Macleod's seminal work of anthropology is one of the most influential studies to address this issue, and — in suggesting that problems of class, above all, help to fuel continued social inequality, Macleod is engaging in an important piece of problem-solving.
He doesn't pull any punches; he holds his subjects accountable for their actions, whether positive or negative. In what way do the Brothers differ from the HH in their values, norms, and group structure?
Yet he does so with gracious humanity, possibly because of his calling as a minister of the gospel. The Brothers understood the racial situation in America to have been vastly improved since the time of their parents.
Includes bibliographical references p. On the other hand, the Brothers play by the rules of the American ideology and the American dream and they have no respect for the bad behavior of the Hallway Hangers. What is the difference between a career and a job?
McLeod argues that some of the Hallway Hangers are reconstructing the meaning of being a father in order to maintain their sense of masculinity. What is the research question which McLeod is trying to address in this study?
First, although the Hallway Hangers' parents wanted their children to do well, they knew from their own experience that encouraging high aspirations would only set them up for failure and disappointment.
The other group, primarily black, believes in the popularly accepted achievement ideology that says that you can do and be anything as long as you work hard enough at it, and thus they work hard in school and generally refrain from smoking and drinking.
He is a clear and descriptive writer, who does well to break down theory into very consumable pieces and tells the story of the Brothers and the Hallway Hangers in such a way that the reader is able to come to see both the structural challenges these young men are dealing with as well as the individual obstacles they must overcome as well.
Aspirations of the Hangers and Brothers 6. Doubts, Dilemmas, and Discoveries-- Second Harvest: In what way, according to Bowles and Gintis, is the structure of schooling in the US reflective of the capitalist economic relations according to Marx? Whereas the Hallway Hangers recognized that they failed to succeed financially because of their position in the lower class, they could not see that class exploitation was also responsible for the financial failure of African Americans.
This shows that schools are preparing kids for the type of work their parents participate in blue collar vs. For those who disagree with the achievement ideology, this difference in attitude is most likely the result of an oppositional response to negative institutional and structural forces.
Their belief in meritocracy, and their hard work in school, allowed them to overcome the racism and class structures that defeated their aspirations in the outside world. Instead he concentrated solely on the role of race and class.In this paper I will explore some concepts that I saw that were prevalent in her undercover research.
Weberian Sociology The first concept that I immediately grasped was Max Weber’s theory of stratification of equality. Weber’s view of stratification differed from the one-dimensional class theory of Karl Marx.
Weber theorized that there are three different [ ]. Ain't no Makin' it is a book about a sociological study and its results conducted by Jay MacLeod It is a story about two groups of men the Hallway Hangers and the Brothers These two groups both live in the housing projects called Clarendon Heights located in Syracuse, New York.
Get this from a library! Ain't no makin' it: aspirations and attainment in a low-income neighborhood. [Jay MacLeod] -- "The author immersed himself in the teenage underworld of Clarendon Heights. The Hallway Hangers, one of the neighborhood cliques, appear as cynical self-destructive hoodlums.
The other group, the. Ain t No Making It Chapter Summaries Essay. Words Dec 19th, 37 Pages.
Chapter 1 Our achievement ideology is based on the idea that the U.S. is full of opportunity and anyone can accomplish success in our society if they work hard enough. Many grow up thinking education is the ladder that will allow for this social mobility and all you.
Kirsten Young Mr. Kersey AP English Composition May 26th, Zayn It Ain’t So Did you hear that? That was the sound of a million teenage girl hearts breaking around the globe, Zayn Malik, an English singer and song writer has found a new direction and it’s stepping out of the spotlight.
I ain't goin' to college. Who wants to go to college? I'd just end up gettin' a shitty job anyway. So said Freddie Piniella, an eleven-year-old boy from Clarendon Heights low-income housing project, to Jay MacLeod, his counselor in a youth program.Download